Purpose and recommendation
Councils should adopt a transparent methodology that links service standards and funding responsibilities to demonstrated public benefit. Service reviews should establish what will be provided, to whom, at what standard, by whom and how its operating and asset costs will be funded sustainably.
The proposed approach comprises three funding categories: community funded, shared funding and user funded. These categories should apply to distinct service components, rather than automatically to an entire program or facility. Specialised standards above council’s adopted community baseline should ordinarily be fully funded by the users who require them.
Transparency and consistent treatment are essential. Comparable users should be assessed against the same published criteria. Any different treatment must arise from an available policy provision and documented evidence, rather than an individually negotiated concession.
The problem to be resolved
Services can accumulate higher standards without a corresponding decision about who should pay. Historical practices then become expectations, while user charges bear little relationship to the cost or distribution of benefits. Specialist labour, plant, weekend servicing and asset renewal can become embedded in the (rates) budget without a clear public benefit assessment.
Consultation can reinforce this problem if users are asked whether they value a service without being shown its full cost. Demand for a heavily subsidised service does not demonstrate willingness to fund it at its actual price.
Elected members face understandable pressure to protect clubs and community organisations from higher charges. If fees are negotiated separately from subsidies, council absorbs the balance by default. This can create inconsistent treatment, weaken financial sustainability and direct support towards the strongest advocates rather than the strongest community outcomes.
The methodology must therefore make both the subsidy and the opportunity cost explicit. Every additional rates contribution reduces the funds available for other services, asset renewal or other community priorities.
Defining broad public benefit
For this framework, broad public benefit means demonstrable outcomes extending beyond the immediate enjoyment, convenience or competitive advantage of identifiable users. Relevant outcomes may include accessible public space, community health, inclusion, social connection and participation by residents facing barriers.
Broad public benefit does not require every resident to use a service. A targeted program can produce a substantial public benefit. Conversely, public ownership, not-for-profit status, tradition or the existence of a membership base does not by itself establish an entitlement to subsidy.
Assessments should consider who benefits, how widely benefits extend, whether access is genuinely available, which barriers are addressed, and what outcomes would be lost without support. They should also consider whether a lower-cost option could achieve comparable outcomes and whether beneficiaries extend beyond the municipality.
Evidence should include utilisation, participant characteristics in aggregate, access arrangements, participation barriers, available alternatives and relevant outcome measures. Club advocacy should inform the assessment but should not substitute for evidence. Broad claims about health or social connection must explain why the particular service standard warrants support.
Public benefit establishes a case for considering subsidy; it does not automatically determine its amount. The subsidy must also be proportionate, affordable and consistent with council priorities.
Funding categories and thresholds
| Category | Assessment threshold | Funding responsibility |
| Community funded | Benefits are predominantly collective, or charging would materially undermine the agreed public purpose. | Rates fund the efficient cost of the adopted baseline, subject to the approved budget |
| Shared funding | There is demonstrable public benefit alongside identifiable user benefit from organised, allocated or exclusive use. | Users contribute from the commencement of that service component; rates fund only the explicitly approved public benefit share. |
| User funded | The component predominantly benefits identifiable users, or provides a specialised or enhanced standard above the adopted baseline without a separately justified public benefit subsidy. | Users meet 100% of its full attributable cost. |
User contributions should therefore commence when a defined service provides identifiable user benefit beyond the collectively funded component. Full cost recovery should commence at the boundary of an additional, user-selected standard where no public subsidy has been justified.
These are proposed policy tests, not universal statutory classifications. Elite or regional competition may trigger assessment of enhanced standards, but competition labels alone should not determine funding. Wider public benefits may justify contributions from neighbouring councils, governments or other partners rather than an automatic subsidy from the host council.
The proposed methodology
Step 1 — Define the service components and intended outcomes.
Separate public access, organised use, specialist preparation and additional competition requirements. Identify existing obligations and commitments that affect implementation. Distinguish the funding decision from the choice of delivery provider.
Step 2 — Adopt the community baseline.
Specify the standard council is prepared to support: access, quality, operating hours, frequency, capacity and asset provision. Establish this through a consistent service policy before determining individual allocations. The baseline must be justified by community need and affordability; it is not simply the current standard renamed.
Step 3 — Assess benefits and alternatives.
Prepare an evidence-based statement of public and user benefits for each component. Compare lower-cost ways of achieving the intended outcome.
Step 4 — Calculate efficient full costs.
Include attributable labour, training, materials, utilities, administration, plant ownership and maintenance, asset consumption and lifecycle requirements. Allocate shared costs on a documented basis. Show both long-term cost and the expenditure that can actually be avoided in the short term.
Step 5 — Set the proposed funding split.
Apply the category tests, determine the dollar value of the justified subsidy and calculate the user contribution required to meet the balance. Test the total against council’s subsidy budget. A funding gap must trigger an explicit choice about funding, standard, scope or continuation; it must not silently default to rates.
Step 6 — Test willingness to pay.
Present priced options and obtain commitments before continuing or investing in enhanced provision. (The detailed process is set out below.)
Step 7 — Adopt and implement the decision.
Record standards, charges, subsidies, delivery responsibilities, renewal obligations and review dates in service agreements and budgets. Provide reasonable transition arrangements under published criteria.
Step 8 — Monitor and reassess.
Report actual costs, revenue, utilisation, outcomes and subsidy against the approved position. Review charges annually and reassess the underlying benefit and service standard periodically, or when material changes occur.
Testing willingness to pay for enhanced services
The term “gold plated” describes concern about excessive provision, but formal assessments should use “enhanced or specialised services” and define the additional standard precisely.
First, provide users with the baseline option and clearly specified enhanced alternatives. Show the full attributable seasonal or annual price, inclusions, exclusions, usage assumptions and arrangements for cancellations or additional work. Explain the costing basis and permit users to identify errors or propose efficient alternatives.
Second, identify the responsible payer (buyer). This will normally be the club, association, hirer or other entity controlling the booking. Where several users share a facility, allocate costs through a published basis such as bookings, hours, wickets prepared or capacity reserved. Council should not assume how a club will distribute its charge among members.
Third, give users a reasonable decision period and request a written commitment to the priced option. Expressions of support or hypothetical survey responses are insufficient evidence of funded demand. Where appropriate, confirm minimum bookings or an agreement before committing expenditure.
Fourth, assess alternatives if users decline. These may include a lower standard, shared venues, fewer prepared wickets, qualified alternative providers or withdrawal of the enhanced component. Alternative delivery must address safety, competition requirements and asset protection. The cost estimate should represent efficient provision.
Finally, distinguish inability to pay from unwillingness to pay. Any participation assistance should be assessed under published eligibility criteria and separately budgeted. It should not conceal the true price or automatically expand the general subsidy.
Guidelines for elected members
Council should adopt the assessment criteria, baseline standards and overall subsidy budget before deciding individual cases. Officers should assess applications consistently; elected members should determine policy and approve subsidies through the applicable decision process.
Each decision report should disclose the full cost, external funding, user contribution, council subsidy in dollars and percentage, intended public outcomes, alternatives, financial implications and review date. Useful comparisons include subsidy per participant or hour, but these should not replace judgement about access and outcomes.
No special treatment means consistent rules and evidence, rather than identical charges irrespective of circumstances. Differences may be justified by demonstrated disadvantage, junior participation, access commitments or measurable outcomes, provided the same criteria are available to comparable applicants.
Individual lobbying, historical influence, club prominence or a threatened withdrawal should not independently justify a concession. Relevant representations should be documented and considered through the common assessment process.
Any proposed departure must identify the policy basis, evidence, additional subsidy, funding source, duration and implications for comparable users. If no existing criterion supports the proposal, council should consider a transparent policy amendment applying to all eligible users. One-off concessions should not bypass this discipline.
Every fee reduction must be accompanied by an explicit decision to increase a funded subsidy, reduce the service cost or secure another funding source. Transitional assistance should have a defined end date and should not become an automatic recurring entitlement.
Council should publish an annual register of service subsidies and approved departures, including material in-kind support and fee waivers, subject to legitimate privacy and confidentiality requirements. Recipients should report against agreed commitments. Established conflict-of-interest and decision-recording arrangements should apply.
Application to turf cricket
A reserve can deliver broad public open-space benefits while also supporting organised sport and specialised competition requirements. These components should be assessed separately.
If council adopts a suitable synthetic wicket as its community cricket baseline, turf provision becomes an additional service choice. The attributable additional costs of specialist preparation, training, rolling and mowing equipment, renovation and weekend servicing would ordinarily be recovered fully from users. Existing ordinary ground contributions must be recognised so the same costs are not charged twice.
Users should receive a credible seasonal price and alternatives before council commits to ongoing enhanced provision. If users will not fund that standard, council should reconsider the standard or arrangement. Any continued subsidy must pass the same published public benefit test applied to comparable services.
Recommended policy position
Council should adopt a service funding and subsidy policy, pilot it across a small range of contrasting services and publish the resulting assessments before broader implementation. The pilot should test costing consistency, practical charging arrangements and equity across users without creating negotiated exemptions.
The governing principle should be that rates fund an explicitly justified community commitment, users contribute towards identifiable benefits, and enhanced standards are fully user funded unless an evidenced subsidy is approved through consistent public rules. Service reviews should conclude with a service specification, a disclosed funding allocation and a sustainable lifecycle funding plan.
0 Comments